TB3 wrote:mooshie wrote:interesting theorybut one slight alteration might make a little more sense, the universe isn't being erased, that particular branch of time is being erased, to explain, scientists now believe that time may branch off due to the endless possibilities of all scenarios and as three dimentional creatures we may only travel in a ray of time as we are not conscious of even moving through the fourth dimention (time), so to sum up, what may be happening is the STM traverses time in the second dimension (side to side) and deletes that branch of time, and while doing so sends the brains on a certain list (the gang) to the branch of time in which XANA never attackedyour-devirtualization wrote: the "bubble" which you referred to is actually what we think is the universe/reality itself being erased as the gang's memories are being sent back in time.
The problem is that the 'multiverse' theory raises a few problems which might have become apparent in the show by now, such as the group noticing differences between realities - also it implies the unpleasant notion that they thus abandon that time-line to it's fate, and everyone within it - also Franz used the RTTP over 2000 times to save himself with the specific intention of saving Aelita, I doubt he would willingly allow any version of his daughter to be erased, which being the genius and Projenitor of Hopperian Physics that he is, would have known would occur in the 'multiverse' theory.
Therefore, in the show Time is clearly a linear quanity, artistically supported by the phrase 'Return to the past'. Therefore:
A CONVENTIONAL TIMELINE
A>================================>B
A TIMELINE DISRUPTED BY AN RTTP
/============<=======\
A>====================---------NEVER OCCURS-------------B
THE RESULT
A----------------------------ERASED-------------------------------B
\==========NEW FLOW OF EVENTS===========>C
The main problem of course is the 'paradox' of that, if the original timeline no-longer exists, how do the kids or computer retain memory of it - and if they don't remember, then XANA will attack again, they will RTTP, repeat ad infinitum stuck in a loop.
The best explanation is the concept of the 'self-healing' timeline - that there is enough 'flux' in space-time to allow paradox without distructive consequence.
Hope this helps, and thanks to all the guys who posted.
Oh, and to officially Knight Lani as a Lyokologist
And now, for Jerfied to join in!
Okay, I have something to add to TB3's comment. I noticed in your 3rd diagram that timeline AB changed to AC. I have an addition to this:
A.......O=============B (O = universal point in timeline, periods = already happened, "=" = future timeline)
A....................OX======B (X = RTTP)
A-v...................X------------B (dashes = never happen)
\O================C
A-------v...........X------------B (The "v" stands for the memories: it would be continuously flowing from the previous timeline and re-entering the time stream)
\......O=============C
A--------------v.X------------B
\.................O========C
A----------------X------------B
\...............................O==C