Moderators: The Administrators, Moderators
kindpastor wrote:You obviously only read the headline of this stroy or heard about it from an unreliable source--this story was reported many places, I was amazed at the amount of facts left out many of the articles I read, including:
1.The man claimed he had a bomb
2The man assualted the Air marshall
If a man claiming he had a bomb in his carry on suddenly ran at you with it--well I don't know what you personally would do in that situation. BTW it turns out this guy had bi-polar disorder--I've got a friend with the same thing and he ALWAYS takes his pills--unlike this individual who felt the need to skip them.
KarinBerry wrote:kindpastor wrote:You obviously only read the headline of this stroy or heard about it from an unreliable source--this story was reported many places, I was amazed at the amount of facts left out many of the articles I read, including:
1.The man claimed he had a bomb
2The man assualted the Air marshall
If a man claiming he had a bomb in his carry on suddenly ran at you with it--well I don't know what you personally would do in that situation. BTW it turns out this guy had bi-polar disorder--I've got a friend with the same thing and he ALWAYS takes his pills--unlike this individual who felt the need to skip them.
sorry I'm jumping in late on this one, and this is somewhat off topic, but I feel like I need to throw in my two cents.
Kindpastor, I have bipolar disorder, as does my sister. We are two very different cases, though.
I experience more lows than highs, and these lows are crippling. I've failed classes and missed work because I can barely get myself out of bed to face the day. Just a few days ago, on Christmas Eve, I was so inexplicably depressed that I missed church with my family (I don't do church, really, but it meant a lot to my father, who is religious, and I really wanted to go for him). I could not stop crying. When they came home, I had finally calmed down, but I could not get off the couch. With the new year, I'll have my mental health coverage back, and I will be finding a psychiatrist to visit to see about getting myself put back on some meds. I'm trying to graduate this Spring and I'm working two jobs, and I'm not going to let my mood disorder get in the way of that, lows and highs be darned.
My sister experiences fantastic manic episodes. She rarely gets depressed (though, when she does, it's as bad as mine). She refuses to take medicine for her mood swings. I don't blame her, really. Why take pills to get rid of something that feels <i>good</i>? In reality, she just doesn't think she'd ill. In her mind, sickness should hurt. As a result, she finds herself in the throes of a manic phase, which can be just as destructive as a depressive phase. She spends money and stays out all night. Her bahaviour is erratic and unplanned, and her speech is so rapid no one can understand her. She usually ends up cutting or dying her hair, or piercing another body part. In the old days, she'd run out and get high. In large part, the definiteion of insanity is not understanding the consequences of your actions. I'd say she qualifies for that when she's manic.
So, just to give this dead guy the benfit of the doubt, let's just say that maybe he was like my sister, and that's why he chose to 'skip' his meds. It's not that he was irresponsible, but that he didn't feel he needed them at all. Sadly, that is <i>part of the illness</i>. If he was in the midst of his highest high or lowest low, he had no idea what was going on or what he was doing. He did the only thing he knew how in order to get himself off that plane, where he knew he <i>did not want to be</i>. No one would let him off the easy way, so he claimed he had a bomb. It got him off the plane, but it also got him killed. It's sad and very messed up, in my mind.
kindpastor wrote:KarinBerry wrote:kindpastor wrote:You obviously only read the headline of this stroy or heard about it from an unreliable source--this story was reported many places, I was amazed at the amount of facts left out many of the articles I read, including:
1.The man claimed he had a bomb
2The man assualted the Air marshall
If a man claiming he had a bomb in his carry on suddenly ran at you with it--well I don't know what you personally would do in that situation. BTW it turns out this guy had bi-polar disorder--I've got a friend with the same thing and he ALWAYS takes his pills--unlike this individual who felt the need to skip them.
sorry I'm jumping in late on this one, and this is somewhat off topic, but I feel like I need to throw in my two cents.
Kindpastor, I have bipolar disorder, as does my sister. We are two very different cases, though.
I experience more lows than highs, and these lows are crippling. I've failed classes and missed work because I can barely get myself out of bed to face the day. Just a few days ago, on Christmas Eve, I was so inexplicably depressed that I missed church with my family (I don't do church, really, but it meant a lot to my father, who is religious, and I really wanted to go for him). I could not stop crying. When they came home, I had finally calmed down, but I could not get off the couch. With the new year, I'll have my mental health coverage back, and I will be finding a psychiatrist to visit to see about getting myself put back on some meds. I'm trying to graduate this Spring and I'm working two jobs, and I'm not going to let my mood disorder get in the way of that, lows and highs be darned.
My sister experiences fantastic manic episodes. She rarely gets depressed (though, when she does, it's as bad as mine). She refuses to take medicine for her mood swings. I don't blame her, really. Why take pills to get rid of something that feels <i>good</i>? In reality, she just doesn't think she'd ill. In her mind, sickness should hurt. As a result, she finds herself in the throes of a manic phase, which can be just as destructive as a depressive phase. She spends money and stays out all night. Her bahaviour is erratic and unplanned, and her speech is so rapid no one can understand her. She usually ends up cutting or dying her hair, or piercing another body part. In the old days, she'd run out and get high. In large part, the definiteion of insanity is not understanding the consequences of your actions. I'd say she qualifies for that when she's manic.
So, just to give this dead guy the benfit of the doubt, let's just say that maybe he was like my sister, and that's why he chose to 'skip' his meds. It's not that he was irresponsible, but that he didn't feel he needed them at all. Sadly, that is <i>part of the illness</i>. If he was in the midst of his highest high or lowest low, he had no idea what was going on or what he was doing. He did the only thing he knew how in order to get himself off that plane, where he knew he <i>did not want to be</i>. No one would let him off the easy way, so he claimed he had a bomb. It got him off the plane, but it also got him killed. It's sad and very messed up, in my mind.
Ok--based on the (unproven) assumption that this fellow rarely needed his pills and was therefore mildly correct in not taking them, I still don't see how this indicts the air marshall of any wrongdoing. Any attempt to do so is just another shot at Americans in general on the part of the disgruntled journalistas who worship the hatred of capitalism
kindpastor wrote:KarinBerry wrote:kindpastor wrote:You obviously only read the headline of this stroy or heard about it from an unreliable source--this story was reported many places, I was amazed at the amount of facts left out many of the articles I read, including:
1.The man claimed he had a bomb
2The man assualted the Air marshall
If a man claiming he had a bomb in his carry on suddenly ran at you with it--well I don't know what you personally would do in that situation. BTW it turns out this guy had bi-polar disorder--I've got a friend with the same thing and he ALWAYS takes his pills--unlike this individual who felt the need to skip them.
sorry I'm jumping in late on this one, and this is somewhat off topic, but I feel like I need to throw in my two cents.
Kindpastor, I have bipolar disorder, as does my sister. We are two very different cases, though.
I experience more lows than highs, and these lows are crippling. I've failed classes and missed work because I can barely get myself out of bed to face the day. Just a few days ago, on Christmas Eve, I was so inexplicably depressed that I missed church with my family (I don't do church, really, but it meant a lot to my father, who is religious, and I really wanted to go for him). I could not stop crying. When they came home, I had finally calmed down, but I could not get off the couch. With the new year, I'll have my mental health coverage back, and I will be finding a psychiatrist to visit to see about getting myself put back on some meds. I'm trying to graduate this Spring and I'm working two jobs, and I'm not going to let my mood disorder get in the way of that, lows and highs be darned.
My sister experiences fantastic manic episodes. She rarely gets depressed (though, when she does, it's as bad as mine). She refuses to take medicine for her mood swings. I don't blame her, really. Why take pills to get rid of something that feels <i>good</i>? In reality, she just doesn't think she'd ill. In her mind, sickness should hurt. As a result, she finds herself in the throes of a manic phase, which can be just as destructive as a depressive phase. She spends money and stays out all night. Her bahaviour is erratic and unplanned, and her speech is so rapid no one can understand her. She usually ends up cutting or dying her hair, or piercing another body part. In the old days, she'd run out and get high. In large part, the definiteion of insanity is not understanding the consequences of your actions. I'd say she qualifies for that when she's manic.
So, just to give this dead guy the benfit of the doubt, let's just say that maybe he was like my sister, and that's why he chose to 'skip' his meds. It's not that he was irresponsible, but that he didn't feel he needed them at all. Sadly, that is <i>part of the illness</i>. If he was in the midst of his highest high or lowest low, he had no idea what was going on or what he was doing. He did the only thing he knew how in order to get himself off that plane, where he knew he <i>did not want to be</i>. No one would let him off the easy way, so he claimed he had a bomb. It got him off the plane, but it also got him killed. It's sad and very messed up, in my mind.
Ok--based on the (unproven) assumption that this fellow rarely needed his pills and was therefore mildly correct in not taking them, I still don't see how this indicts the air marshall of any wrongdoing.
KarinBerry wrote:
I didn't say he didn't need them. I used my sister and myself as an example of the different ways the illness can inflict people. My sister needs pills as badly as I do, because her manic phases are just as destructive as my depressive phases. My point was that if he was, in fact, stricken with bipolar disorder, he may have been one of those individuals who didn't suffer many lows and therefore did not consider themselves ill enough to require medicine. That would have been his perception, but not the truth, as the truth would be that he needed the pills badly.
The whole thing could have been avoided if they had just let him off the plane when he made his request.They did do this, he claimed he had a bomb and ran towards the air marshall after he had left the plain, at least according to CNN's account His ticket was paid for, he was a legal passenger on the plane, and he changed his mind for whatever reasons.Don't forget the bomb threat If I were a flight attendant, I would have let him off when he asked. In my mind, I'd rationalise it with "hey, do I really want to listen to this guy complain for the whole flight that we didn't let him off?"
And then I just think it's unfortunate, because people, in this whole terrorist uproar, have begun to impliment the "shoot first; as questions later" action plan. In my opinion, they could have attempted to think clearly about the situation and they would have realised that a <i>bomb</i> in his <i>carry-on bag</i> would have been detected by the screening process that everyone (passengers and employees) go through to access the airport terminals. But, no. They got him off the plane, and they shot him.Who says they thought he had a bomb in his carry-on? Who is to say they didn't think he had the detanator to a bomb in the luggage compartment, or some other such contingency? If a man runs at you claiming he has a bomb and your advice is not to shoot him you are a misguided individual
I'm not saying this incriminates the Air Marshall in any way. He was probably following a set plan of action, one of those things they train for 'in the event of...[insert crisis here].'
Anyway, I'm not defending or accusing anyone in the situation. I just thought the guy who died deserved a little more credit than everyone seems to be giving him. I thought that maybe, with my experiences, I could shine a little light on what, perhaps, might be closer to the truth than what gets played on the news and stuff.You seemed to imply that the air marshall was at fault with your statements like "people should have [thought] clearly about the situation, and mentioning the "shoot first, ask questions later" action plan--which was not implimented at all
Paige wrote:With that, I am going to stop voicing my opinions, I don't want the world to be against me. I don't really think everything that I do or say out first, and that is not really very good, but that's how I am. So with mattters such as politics, which is very important to me, I am going to back down and just leave with saying....
BUSH ROCKS!
LucyMcGonagle wrote:Bush is an idiot. He keeps promising that he's gonna bring the soldiers back, but nooo....he doesn't. He keeps saying that we're gonna find oil, but we don't. He keeps saying there's weapons in Iraq, but they must be invisable....
Yes, we've had worse leaders, but someone needs to give him a good swift kick in the head....
Dr. Cheese wrote:LucyMcGonagle wrote:Bush is an idiot. He keeps promising that he's gonna bring the soldiers back, but nooo....he doesn't. He keeps saying that we're gonna find oil, but we don't. He keeps saying there's weapons in Iraq, but they must be invisable....
Yes, we've had worse leaders, but someone needs to give him a good swift kick in the head....
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest